Super Bowl 44 In The History Books: Perhaps The Who Should Follow

6 161

My objectivity concerning this story will surely be questioned by fans of The Who, however, where that group is concerned, I’ve always considered myself more neutral than not. I’ve never considered myself a fan. They’re music just never did anything for me, so I pretty much ignored them.

Still, there’s no way to be unfamiliar with hits like “My Generation,” “Baba O’Riley,” or “ Pinball Wizard,” and I do recall how those songs sounded when The Who was in their prime, and Sunday’s half-time performance at the big game didn’t cut it– or even come close.

There are a number of writers on the internet that are accusing the NFL of playing it safe after the infamous and family-unfriendly Janet Jackson “wardrobe malfunction” a few years back. Sticking to classic rock acts like The Who or Springsteen is seen by some as the league’s way of keeping things predictable and G-rated for the NFL’s family-friendly image.

Normally, I would be the first to come to the defense of a classic rock act being showcased at an event like the Super Bowl, but only if the performers are still capable of performing. I thought the vocals delivered by both Daltrey and Townshend were sub par at best. Personally, I would have much rather seen Daughtry instead of Daltrey.

The stage was cool, the lasers were cool, and, unfortunately, the performance was cool as well – as in “not hot.” There was talk that the veteran rockers would be accompanied by some pre-recorded material. I was left with little doubt after a performance that seemed to feature the two rock stars, a drummer, and a few other musicians in the shadows who may as well have been sleeping as far as I could tell.

Kudos to whomever synched up the timing on the pre-recorded version of Daltrey’s signature scream during “Won’t Get Fooled Again,” however. Even so, I don’t think too many people with a fully-functioning pair of ears were fooled into believing that it came from the 2010 version of Roger Daltrey. Some of those keyboard passages were a little too pure and true to the original to be believed as well.

To no one’s surprise, I often find myself in disagreement with those who take shots at classic rockers with comments that declare that they are too old to walk without assistance, or will require oxygen after their performance because they’re in their late 50’s or 60’s, but as I watched yesterday’s half-time show, I found myself afloat in the same boat.

Sure, there are aging rock stars out there who are still able to get up there and put on a good show. A good many of them are still recording as well. The demand is obviously still there, and I’m happy to go along as long as the artists hold up their end of the deal.

I’m not saying they should throw Daltrey and Townshend in jail or anything, and I’m not even going to touch the whole pedophile scandal thing – as far as I’m concerned, people have to decide for themselves on that one, since the authorities in the U.K. kind of left the world hanging regarding exactly what went on.

Besides, we have Townshend’s own comments – regarding Yoko Ono, of all people – as evidence that perhaps he’s gone ’round the bend, as they say.

Following their performance, Townshend was, of course, asked about the pedophile thing, and answered as one might expect. What was really interesting, however, was when the duo was asked about their experience at the “Rock and Roll Circus” – a 1968 event that included The Who, The Rolling Stones, John Lennon and, of course, Yoko Ono.

While Daltrey spoke with sadness about his last meeting with The Stones’ Brian Jones before his death, Townshend ceased the opportunity to gush about Yoko Ono, declaring that he thinks she’s “amazing,” and insisting, “No really, I am one of the select [band of] Yoko Ono fans.” A statement that, according to The Times, even prompted a “mutter of disbelief” from Daltrey.

Well, at least Daltrey got that right.



  1. Brady Russell February 8, 2010 at 11:16 am

    Quote: “Still, there’s no way to be unfamiliar with hits like “Teenage Wasteland,” “Bubba O’Riley,” ……

    Um…it’s “Baba O’Riley”, and there’s no such song as “Teenage Wasteland”.

    But thanks for playing.

    • Real Rock News February 8, 2010 at 11:26 am

      Well, I did say I was not a fan of The Who, so there’s your proof.

      I’ll make the necessary corrections.

      But thanks for stopping by to demonstrate your vast knowledge for us mere mortals, your Highness.

  2. Brad February 8, 2010 at 3:54 pm

    It’s hard to take Super Bowl halftime shows seriously, since they are more akin to a 3-ring circus than a musical act. But like the game itself, it does showcase our heroes, even if very heavily condensed.

    But it sure beats Up With People and marching bands, as was common in the Super Bowl’s early days.

    • Real Rock News February 9, 2010 at 9:21 am

      I don’t write about sports for the same reason this guy should not be writing about music!

      Oy vey!

  3. Dave February 9, 2010 at 1:35 pm

    Well, I believe that if you are not a fan of The Who, you will tend to be more critical of The Who. With that said, I think their performance was everything it could be at this juncture but not because of age. If you watch Townsend, he is seriously kicking A$$. I believe they have not been able to recapture the ferociousness of their performance since John Entwhistle died. I believe that took a lot of the life out of them. Pino Pallidino adds absolutely nothing to The Who except a solid backbone. No energy, no life. Entwhistle added LIFE!! Watch the Who’s performance in 2001 at the NYC 9/11 benefit at MSG. They were stellar…on fire if you will. That wasn’t that long ago age-wise.

    Do I think they should give it up??? I believe they probably should have once Entwhistle died. But not because of age…because his death killed their UMPH…it killed their magic.

    Have a lovely day 🙂

    • Real Rock News February 9, 2010 at 2:11 pm

      Yeah, that’s probably true. I probably am more critical of The Who, but I’ve also run into a few other reviews that ripped their performance pretty badly, and they were coming from people who claimed to be die-hard The Who fans. Glad to provide references to anyone who would like them.

      Anyway, since we’ve all acknowledged the fact that I am not a fan, I’ll take your word for it that the passing of Entwhistle took a lot of the group’s energy with him. However, I’m sticking to my guns on the age thing. My main criticism of the performance was due to the vocals and not so much Townshend’s guitar work. There’s no getting away from the fact that you just can’t belt it out at 65 like you did when you were 25.

      Be that as it may, thanks for the considered and thoughtful comment. Dissenting opinion is always welcome as long as it is done in a civil manner.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *